AdBlocker active?
It seems you are using software to block advertisements. You could help us if you could switch it off when visiting RedZoneClash.org.
The reason is very simple: Advertisements help us running the site, to offer you the game in a good quality for free. So if you like the game, please support us by purchasing a Supporter Account or disabling the AdBlocker on this site.
Thank you very much!
| Main / Discussions / Best QB in league awards / Best position generally Search Forum | |
| Navigation: |< >| | |
| Poster | Message |
|
mrrich
|
posted: 2013-09-23 18:15:21 (ID: 831) Report Abuse |
|
I can't really tell what this is based on, I'd love to know, as I just looked up who was the Best QB season one in Crimson Tide. This is his stats:
1342 Plays 424 of 792 (54% Completion) 3873 Yards (4.9 average) 28 Tds 25 Interceptions 65.7 QB Rating 8 rushes for 50 Yards. Now, I'm not saying my QB was the best by any shadow of a doubt, as I haven't been through everyone else in the league... but here's his stats. 609 Plays 107 of 237 (45% Completion) 1373 Yards (5.8 Average) 15 Tds 4 Interceptions 77.9 QB Rating On this logic it seems that the QBs are doing better if they play more downs (would make sense) and pass for a lot of yards. Seems they're not getting punished for QB Rating of interceptions much. The 2nd QB in Crimson tide had a much better TD/Interception ratio, less yards, but much higher QB Rating. |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
Bovakian
|
posted: 2013-09-23 18:35:59 (ID: 833) Report Abuse |
|
mrrich wrote:
I can't really tell what this is based on, I'd love to know, as I just looked up who was the Best QB season one in Crimson Tide. This is his stats: 1342 Plays 424 of 792 (54% Completion) 3873 Yards (4.9 average) 28 Tds 25 Interceptions 65.7 QB Rating 8 rushes for 50 Yards. Now, I'm not saying my QB was the best by any shadow of a doubt, as I haven't been through everyone else in the league... but here's his stats. 609 Plays 107 of 237 (45% Completion) 1373 Yards (5.8 Average) 15 Tds 4 Interceptions 77.9 QB Rating On this logic it seems that the QBs are doing better if they play more downs (would make sense) and pass for a lot of yards. Seems they're not getting punished for QB Rating of interceptions much. The 2nd QB in Crimson tide had a much better TD/Interception ratio, less yards, but much higher QB Rating. I think you'll find that QB, RB, FB, WR & TE rankings are based on yardage. |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
nobody
|
posted: 2013-09-23 19:01:59 (ID: 835) Report Abuse |
|
Well we made it thru season 1 and season 2 looks to be a little better for us.
Phillip Strein . Awards achieved by player: Best QB of the Region Sooners in Season 1 with E.S.C (318) Best QB of the League Sooners 1.1 in Season 1 with E.S.C (318) |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
Buffalo
|
posted: 2013-10-08 06:19:01 (ID: 913) Report Abuse |
|
Most important category for all player is putting points on the score board. More yards and less turnovers help, too.
Forget the ratio. |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
mrrich
|
posted: 2013-10-08 09:08:18 (ID: 914) Report Abuse |
|
Buffalo wrote:
Most important category for all player is putting points on the score board. More yards and less turnovers help, too. Forget the ratio. I don't think Tom Brady, Peyton Manning etc would agree. Take a look at the NFL in 2006. Carson Palmer put up the 2nd highest amount of TDs that year and the fifth highest number of yards. However for every two TDs he threw, he threw an INT. Sure, he went to the pro bowl, but then again so did Vince Young for some unknown reason. But Cincinnati were 8-8. Turnovers. |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
bwadders76
|
posted: 2013-10-20 16:24:57 (ID: 943) Report Abuse |
|
mrrich wrote:
Buffalo wrote:
Most important category for all player is putting points on the score board. More yards and less turnovers help, too. Forget the ratio. I don't think Tom Brady, Peyton Manning etc would agree. Take a look at the NFL in 2006. Carson Palmer put up the 2nd highest amount of TDs that year and the fifth highest number of yards. However for every two TDs he threw, he threw an INT. Sure, he went to the pro bowl, but then again so did Vince Young for some unknown reason. But Cincinnati were 8-8. Turnovers. I may be speaking out of turn here but I do not think that the engine has the ability to create any filters so any other way of deciding things could end up with a QB playing 1 snap, 1 pass, 1 completion for 1 TD and end up winning the award because his rating would be highest. IRL it's easy to set a minimum number of attempts to determine the winner but in this game I don't think that's a possibility at the moment. |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
mrrich
|
posted: 2013-10-21 08:30:58 (ID: 944) Report Abuse |
|
If it's using an SQL based database, it's easy to only call responses that have a minimum number of attempts. However, I don't know what he's using for the database.
|
|
| Quote Reply | |
| posted: 2013-10-21 15:51:32 (ID: 945) Report Abuse | |
|
postgresql
I do not get the full story, what's the problem? |
|
| Quote Reply | |
|
mrrich
|
posted: 2014-05-19 18:02:35 (ID: 1414) Report Abuse |
|
I was only saying (big gap in conversation) that surely we could be working more of say a QB rating system. The minimum amount of attempts would be easy to do.
Also, is my QB still the best in the game? |
|
| Quote Reply | |
| reply Mark this thread unread | |
| Navigation: |< >| | |
| Main / Discussions / Best QB in league awards / Best position generally | |
